Are You Covered If Your Insurer Pays Only Depreciated Value for Your Roof?
Actual cash value subtracts depreciation. Even a replacement-cost policy may settle an older roof at ACV.
After a hailstorm or a named-storm wind event, many coastal homeowners expect the insurer to pay what it actually costs to put a new roof on the house. Sometimes that is what the policy does. Sometimes it is not. If the policy settles the roof at actual cash value, the check may subtract depreciation for age and wear, and the unpaid share can be large on an older roof. The shock is often not that the claim was denied. It is that the claim was paid, just not at the number the contractor quoted.
This page is general information for South Carolina homeowners. It is not a coverage decision, a claim opinion, or legal advice. The declarations page and the roof or settlement language in your form control.
Replacement cost and actual cash value
The South Carolina Department of Insurance explains the two settlement methods this way. Replacement cost is the amount it would take to replace or rebuild your home, or to repair damage, with materials of similar kind and quality, without deducting for depreciation. Actual cash value is the amount it would take to repair or replace the damage after depreciation. The Department also advises insuring the home for at least 80 percent of its replacement value.
The Department’s post-disaster claims guide makes a further point that catches people off guard: even if you bought a replacement-cost policy, there may be other limits on certain surfaces, such as roofs. In some cases, the policy may pay actual cash value on the roof but replacement cost on the rest of the home. If the declarations page does not say replacement cost, the guide says the policy likely covers actual cash value.
The same guide illustrates why depreciation can matter so much on an older roof. It explains that if a covered loss destroys a 20-year-old roof, a replacement-cost policy would cover the full cost to replace it, subject to the policy limit, while an actual-cash-value policy may pay as little as 20 percent of that replacement cost, because the useful life of a roof is usually about 25 years in the Department’s example. That is the Department’s illustration, not a promise about your roof, your contractor’s price, or your claim. It is a reason to read the settlement basis before the storm, not after.
Typical gaps to watch for
- A roof scheduled or endorsed at actual cash value. This is increasingly common on older roofs. The rest of the house may still be at replacement cost.
- A named-storm or wind deductible. On the coast, that deductible is often a percentage of the dwelling limit. It comes off the claim in addition to any depreciation that applies.
- Recoverable depreciation. Some replacement-cost forms pay actual cash value first and release the remaining depreciation only after you actually replace the roof and submit the invoices. If you cash a first check and never do the work, you may never see the rest.
- A dwelling limit that is too low. Replacement-cost language does not help if the limit itself is short of what it costs to rebuild. The Department’s 80 percent guidance is a minimum conversation, not a coastal rebuild formula.
- Wear, poor maintenance, or a roof that was already failing. A policy may not pay to upgrade a roof that was at the end of its life, or to fix leaks that were not caused by the covered storm.
What to do at claim time
Document the roof with photos before repairs if it is safe to do so. Get a written contractor estimate that separates the cost to replace the roof from other repairs. Ask the adjuster, in writing if you can, whether the roof is being settled at replacement cost or actual cash value, and whether any withheld depreciation can be recovered after the work is done. Compare that answer to your declarations page. If the house is open to weather, take reasonable steps to prevent further damage and keep receipts, as the Department has advised after storm losses.
Check your policy
- Does the declarations page say replacement cost or actual cash value for the dwelling?
- Is there a separate roof settlement schedule or an actual-cash-value roof endorsement?
- If the policy is replacement cost, is depreciation held back until I complete the work?
- What is my wind, hail, or named-storm deductible, and is it a percentage?
- Is the dwelling limit still close to what it would cost to rebuild the house today?
FAQ
What is the difference between actual cash value and replacement cost?
Can I have replacement cost on the house but actual cash value on the roof?
Why was my roof check so much smaller than the contractor’s bid?
Does a new roof automatically change my coverage to replacement cost?
Should I wait until after hurricane season to check this?
Related coverage: home insurance. Want us to look at your policy? Request a free review. A review is not a quote, a binder, or a promise that a claim will be paid.
Check my coverageDisclaimer
This article is general information for educational purposes. It is not an insurance quote, offer, binder, or a decision about any claim. It is not legal advice. Coverage depends on the policy language, endorsements, deductibles, the insurance carrier, and the facts of the loss. Harbor One Insurance can review a specific policy on request. South Carolina advertising law requires insurance communications to be truthful and not misleading; nothing here guarantees a particular outcome.
Sources
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, Purchasing Home Insurance Knowledge (replacement cost, actual cash value, and the 80 percent replacement-value guidance): https://www.doi.sc.gov/618/Purchasing-Home-Insurance-Knowledge
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, Post-Disaster Claims Guide (replacement cost versus actual cash value, including roofs): https://doi.sc.gov/DocumentCenter/View/12147/Post-Disaster-Claims-Guide
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, “Making the Claims Process Easier” (documentation and mitigation after a storm): https://www.doi.sc.gov/DocumentCenter/View/8507/October-Storm-Claims-Tips-and-Recovery-Press-Release-10-3-15
More scenarios